New York strip is served at a wide range of restaurants, from local diners to fine-dining establishments, making it a popular and versatile steak enjoyed by many across the nation. However, how much do you know about this well-loved cut? Below, we examine what makes New York strip an iconic steak, along with how to select and prepare it at home like a chef.
Where Does New York Strip Come From?
New York strip comes from the loin subprimal, which is where some of the most tender beef cuts can be found. Located directly behind the rib muscles, the loin subprimal is where popular cuts like the sirloin, short loin, tenderloin, top sirloin, and bottom sirloin come from. New York strip is part of the short loin, making it one of the most tender cuts of beef you can buy.
How New York Strip Got Its Name
Legend has it that the New York strip got its name when Delmonico's, a legendary restaurant in New York City, added this cut to its menu in the 1800s. The name stuck, and the rest is history. Though New York strip is by far this cut's most commonly used name, it's also known as Delmonico steak, ambassador steak, or Kansas City strip.
What Makes New York Strip Unique?
New York strip is perfectly balanced: it offers tenderness without sacrificing the substantial, beefy flavor of other, less tender cuts. This versatility makes it popular among home cooks and restaurant chefs alike. While it’s soft and tender, it is slightly firmer than other loin cuts like filet mignon. New York strip has a distinctive, satisfying texture, and moderate marbling adds to its chew. This results in a flawless blend of robust beef flavor, tenderness, and juiciness
How to Select New York Strip
The key to selecting a great New York strip is to purchase it from a high-quality NYC butcher shop, like Piccinini Bros. in New York City. We custom cut and trim your meat exactly the way you want, so you always get the cut, portions, and weight you're looking for without settling. Look for cuts that are vibrant red in color and have bright white fat streaks throughout (not just on the edges). You should select a cut that’s at least one-inch thick for even cooking and to allow the fat deposits to dissolve adequately.
How Should New York Strip Be Cooked?
New York Strip is versatile and can be cooked in many ways. No matter which preparation method you prefer, let the cut sit out for a few minutes before you cook it, and pat dry to remove excess moisture. Also, use an internal meat thermometer to ensure your steak is at your desired level of doneness. Here are a few of the most popular ways to cook New York strip:
Butter Basting
Cooking steak indoors is super easy. Get a well-seasoned cast-iron skillet hot and sear the steak on both sides. Then, melt a blend of butter, garlic, thyme, and rosemary in the skillet and spoon over the steak to butter baste the meat. Continuously tilt the pan to allow the butter to dissolve into the steak. For a thicker cut, you can place the skillet in the oven afterward to finish it off.
Broiling
Paul Vaccari, owner of Piccinini Bros. butcher shop in NYC, prefers this steak preparation method, especially when cooking at home in his New York City apartment. Place your first oven rack at least 6 inches below the broiler element and turn the broiler on to preheat. Then, line a baking sheet with aluminum foil and place your steaks in the center of the pan, season generously with salt and pepper. Once the broiler is preheated, place the sheet in the oven and cook, flipping the steaks every 2–3 minutes for even cooking, until they reach your preferred internal temperature.
Marinating
You can also marinate New York strip and shred it for recipes like steak fajitas, tacos, kebabs, and stir-fries. Marinate in your preferred flavor blend for 2 to 4 hours before cooking. Be careful not to marinate the cut for too long, or it will become so fall-apart tender that it will be difficult to cook properly.
Grilling
Grilling is a classic way to serve New York strip. Put your grill on high heat (around 400–450°). Once the grill is heated, place your steak directly on the grill and flip every few minutes. Continuously check the temperature to determine when it’s time to take it off the heat; don't solely focus on the cook time.
What Is The Best Way To Season New York Strip?
When you choose a high-quality steak like those from our butcher shop in NYC, it’s best to keep the seasonings simple. All you need is some kosher salt, cracked black pepper, and maybe a little garlic.
Should You Get A Bone-In Or Boneless New York Strip?
It’s a slight point of contention within the meat community about whether a “traditional” New York strip should be bone-in or boneless. Some argue that bone-in New York strip is really Kansas City strip. In New York and surrounding areas, New York strip is often served boneless. However, each type has its own distinct flavor profile, so we recommend trying both to see which you like best. We have both types at our butcher shop in NYC, so you can easily try them and decide for yourself.
Get Your New York Strip At An Authentic Butcher Shop in NYC
We’re an artisanal butcher shop in NYC that’s been around since 1922. We know meat, and we know this city. There’s nothing like the real deal! That’s why we’re proud to supply the finest restaurants in New York City with high-quality meat. Now, you can enjoy the same restaurant-quality cuts at home, including New York strip. Whether you’re grilling outside or cooking indoors, we have the perfect cut for you, trimmed to your exact specifications. Order online, stop by our shop in Hell’s Kitchen, or call us today at 212-246-8277 to place your order.